×
Suggest this Article to:
TOP INDEXERS
Public Article
-
verified
ACKNOWLEDGING OTHERS
ISSN: 2717 - 1159
Publisher: author
ACKNOWLEDGING OTHERS
Indexed in
Philosophy and Religion
ARTICLE-FACTOR
1.3
Article Basics Score: 3
Article Transparency Score: 2
Article Operation Score: 3
Article Articles Score: 2
Article Accessibility Score: 2
SUBMIT PAPER ASK QUESTION
International Category Code (ICC):
ICC-1602
Publisher: University Of Zanjan
International Journal Address (IAA):
IAA.ZONE/271793881159
eISSN
:
2717 - 1159
VALID
ISSN Validator
Abstract
It is widely affirmed that human beings have irreplaceable valuable, and that we owe it to them to treat them accordingly. Many theorists have been drawn to Kantianism because they think that it alone can capture this intuition. One aim of this paper is to show that this is a mistake, and that Kantianism cannot provide an independent rational vindication, nor even a fully illuminating articulation, of irreplaceability. A further aim is to outline a broadly Aristotelian view that provides a more fitting theoretical framework for this appealing conception of human value. This critique of Kantianism extends to contemporary theorists with a broadly Kantian orientation, including Christine Korsgaard, Stephen Darwall and John Rawls. The problem with these views, at heart, is that they attempt to ground morality in respect alone. Yet it is love, not respect, that brings irreplaceability into view. The paper closes with a sketch of a virtue-t...
